Are the Benguet pine forests savannas?
If you look at the landscape in the pictures in my first post, how would you describe it?
If you look at the pine trees, how would you describe them?
If you look at the ground, how would you describe it?
Now look at this.
![]() |
| Benguet pine in Malico |
The edges of the Themeda leaves slide across my arms and slice them like paper. I inhale sharply, the sting of several papercuts peppering my mind. Instantly forgotten, my thoughts turn to my unstable footing as the mat of giant grass gives way to a shallow ditch. I slip.
"What meter are we at?" I ask Hendrix, the graduate student who has already established himself as essential personnel on this project. He has looked at every plant in probably five hundred 1-square-meter sampling plots by now. We plan our trips around his schedule.
Hendrix looks up at the 50-m transect tape strung above our heads. We still have about 10 meters to go before the next groundcover sampling spot.
![]() |
| I'm not sure how they got this tape across a ditch that you can't see |
Every step takes about five seconds here, and I'm stepping sideways so I don't plunge headfirst down the slope. Compared to the process here, in Zambales we were running as we set up the plot!
An enormous Pinus kesiya, or Benguet pine, assists me in stabilizing one foot while the other taps around for the next secure foothold as we continue downward. We don't know how long it's been since fire burned this location, but I can't see anything but grass and shrubs and a pocket of young Benguet pines that must have escaped the last fire. If there are any pine seedlings in this thick grassy ocean, we don't see them.
Hendrix begins assessing the groundcover species while I scrawl some information on the datasheets attached to my clipboard. As I wait for him to being calling out plant names, I look over to the opposite hill.
![]() |
| Benguet pine on the slope |
Compared to those in Zambales, the tree distributions are more clumped - areas with no canopy lie sprawled between pine clusters, occasionally dotted with a tree. The pines themselves seem shorter and more shaggy, with more branches. And then in the ravines between pine savannas are broadleaf forests, almost always along a riverbed.
![]() |
| Broadleaf forest along a river in the gully |
The following day, we established another plot where a wildfire had swept across the hills in April 2024. Although it killed clusters of adult pine trees, there was regeneration.
![]() |
| Recently burned area (2.5 years since fire) |
![]() |
| Benguet pine seedling |
![]() |
| I'm not sure how long it has been since fire on this slope. |
![]() |
| Small fires for grazing animals |
Are fires a natural part of the ecology of this system too?
That's what we're here to find out.








Comments
Post a Comment